Smart Guide To Choosing The Best Innerspring Mattress
In this guide, we will offer an in-depth buyer guide for innerspring mattresses. We will be covering all the key features that you will want to consider before making a purchase.
In addition to this, you will find a summary of the best innerspring mattresses on the market and a brief overview of the top manufacturers of this type of mattress.
Here Are The Top Picks
We’ve analyzed 3176 innerspring mattress reviews (read about our accurate unbiased method), and compared mattresses side-by-side, scored according to a range of factors including comfort, pain relief potential, durability, initial odor and heat retention ability.
Who Should be Interested in Innerspring Mattress?
Innerspring mattresses are best for people who want the more traditional style of mattress with a decent amount of bounce. They are also a good choice if cooling and strong edge support are important factors in a mattress.
Innerspring mattresses are probably the most traditional type of mattress that you can buy. It uses steel coils in the support system. Depending on the mattress, these may be connected in a single unit or they can be individually wrapped pocketed coils. The coils will then be covered with some form of padding – most commonly foam.
Since innerspring mattress have been around for a long time, manufacturers have had ample time to perfect a wide range of feels, firmness levels and support meaning consumers have a huge choice available to them when purchasing an innerspring mattress.
Another common advantage that consumers mention in regard to innerspring mattresses is that they do not tend to suffer from off gassing. This is because there is only a minimal amount of foam used in this type of mattress.
For a similar reason, innerspring mattresses are great for cooling making them more comfortable to sleep on, especially in a hot climate.
Some of the most common downsides that consumers mention in relation to innerspring mattresses are the noise that the springs make and also below average durability/longevity. About 1 in 4 owners report that sagging occurs within the first 3 years making them uncomfortable and lacking in support.
Top 5 Mattresses
The Saatva innerspring mattress features a coil on coil pillow top design. It uses a combination of hourglass and pocketed coils and is available in 3 different firmness options – soft, medium and firm. The base layer is made up of 416 steel hourglass coils and serves as the support layer.
This is topped with a second coil layer featuring 884 individually wrapped contour coils for comfort. There is then a memory foam layer for support and a pillow top comfort layer.
Consumers praise the mattress for the traditional feel and excellent bounce. It also offers great pressure relief. However, it does not perform very well in terms of motion transfer and some consumers feel that it is not as durable as they would like.
WinkBeds are relatively new in the mattress industry, but they are becoming an increasingly popular choice among those looking for an innerspring mattress. The mattress features a coil on coil design starting with a base layer of high density foam followed by a layer of tempered steel coils for consistent support. The third layer is only found on the edges, offering high density memory foam for edge support. The second layer of coils features 1358 pocketed coils for flexible pressure relief and airflow.
The Sapira is a hybrid mattress by Leesa which has a medium to firm rating. It uses a combination of avena foam, memory foam and 1041 high performance pocketed coils. The Sapira mattress is rated highly for support and offers excellent cooling. Consumers also note that it performs very well in motion transfer making it a good choice for those with a restless partner. However, some reviews not that since it is firmer than average, the mattress may not be very comfortable for side sleepers.
Beautyrest Black Mariela
The Beautyrest Black Mariela is a higher end mattress which is highly rated by consumers, but does cost almost twice the price you can expect on similar mattresses. The mattress performs well in terms of comfort, motion isolation and support, but consumers are not so impresses with the heat retention and off gassing.
The Alexander Hybrid mattress from Nest Bedding is available in either medium or luxury firm varieties. It is a hybrid mattress meaning it contains both innersprings and a memory foam layer. The base layer has 1872 pocketed coils and provides deep compression support. The coils are topped with a layer of smartflow foam for transitional support and a layer of copper infused gel memory foam for cooling and comfort. This particular mattress feels more like a memory foam mattress than an innerspring, so it may not be the best choice if you want the traditional coil feel.
How to Choose the Best InnerSpring Mattress
Coil Count & Gauge
One of the things that you will notice when looking at various innerspring mattresses is the coil count and gauge. The coil count refers to the number of coils in the mattress and in theory, the more coils the better the support. However, if the coils are of a lower quality of steel then this may not be the case. The gauge is the thickness of the steel or wire used in the coils. Both need to be considered, so look for a high coil count coupled with a reasonable gauge for maximum support.
Different mattresses make use of different types of coils which have their own advantages and disadvantages. No single type is better than another as you do need to take into account a number of other factors. People assume that pocket coils are best because they are individually wrapped and are great for contouring to the body, but if you have a single unit of interconnected coils with a thick memory foam top layer then you will get a similar result.
Top Layer Above the Springs
One feature that can really make a huge difference to an innerspring mattress is the top layer that lies above the springs. The thickness and material of this layer is going to have a huge impact on the overall feel of the mattress. It is important to pay attention to the different materials and understand the properties and advantages that they have. For example, an innerspring mattress with a thick memory foam top layer will be more conforming, but will lose the feel and support traditionally linked to an innerspring mattress.
Innerspring mattresses do not perform well in terms of longevity and durability. One in every 4 consumers who own an innerspring state that within the first 3 years they began to notice substantial sagging to extent that the mattress began to lose comfort and support. This is a much higher rate than any other type of mattress.
One of the great things about innerspring mattresses is that they do not retain heat. The coil construction allows for air to flow in the mattress resulting in natural cooling. In mattresses which have a memory foam top layer there may be a greater level of heat retention.
Whether or not you require a topper depends on the mattress that you choose. Cheaper innerspring mattresses may have little or no comfort layer will need a mattress topper to make it more comfortable, but if your mattress of choice has a thick comfort layer then it will not usually be necessary.
Smell / Off Gassing
One of the things that many people find so attractive about innerspring mattresses is that they have little to no off gassing. In the small number of cases were consumers have complained of a chemical odour it is related to whether or not memory foam is used in the mattress top layer. Usually, there is not enough foam to cause any significant off gassing.
What to Take into Consideration Buying Mattress Online
When buying an innerspring mattress online, you are going to need to consider that you cannot test it out for appropriate firmness. It is best to look closely at the coil count, coil gauge and the layers in each mattress as this will give you a better idea of the level of firmness and support. Since oyu cannot try it before buying, look for brands that offer a 100 night trial period so that you can return it if it is not working for you. The best source of genuine feedback is to look at consumer reviews on a third party website.
Innerspring Mattress Companies
Saatva – Saatva are one of the most highly rated innerspring mattress companies. Not only do they have an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, but only 4 complaints have been filed in the last 3 years which is almost unheard of for a business this size! Consumers rate the customer service very highly and both the warranty and returns policy are above average.
BeautyRest – Beautyrest mattresses are made by Simmons. This long standing company was founded back in 1870 and has been under its current ownership since 2012. The company maintains an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, but has only an average rating among consumers for customer service. The warranty offered is 10 years, but many consumers complain that it is lacking especially in regard to sagging, but that is a common complaint among innerspring manufacturers.
Serta – Serta has been in business since 1931, although the current ownership only goes back to 2005. They have an A+ rating with the BBB, but consumers say that customer service can be a little hit or miss. The 120 day trial period is longer than average, but a redelivery fee may be charged. The 10 year warranty in non-prorated, but as with most innerspring manufacturers, consumers would prefer more coverage for sagging.